A New Pathway for Quality-Driven Academic Auditing and Evaluation

In the evolving world of academia, how we measure excellence is undergoing a long-overdue transformation. For decades, research output has been judged almost exclusively by where it is published, rather than by the quality, innovation, or societal relevance of the work itself. But now, a growing global movement is challenging this outdated model. At the heart of this shift lies the DORA Declaration—an initiative that is gaining renewed attention this week across research and education sectors.

As an independent inspection body, PINO Switzerland is closely following this development. Although we do not operate under a national authority, we uphold the highest standards of professional integrity and voluntary certification. The DORA Declaration resonates strongly with our mission to promote fair, responsible, and meaningful evaluation practices.

What Is the DORA Declaration Really About?

At its core, the DORA Declaration is a call for reform. It encourages institutions, funders, and evaluators to rethink how they assess scientific research. The message is simple: judge the research on its own merit—not based on the prestige of the journal where it’s published.

Rather than relying on metrics like impact factors or citation counts, DORA promotes a broader, more nuanced view of research quality. This includes looking at:

• The significance and originality of the research

• The transparency and reproducibility of the methodology

• The actual impact on society, industry, or local communities

• The collaboration and inclusiveness of the research process

This approach supports a more inclusive academic environment, where innovation and effort are recognized beyond elite publication channels.

Why It Matters for Quality Auditing

As the academic landscape shifts, inspection bodies like PINO Switzerland must evolve as well. In our voluntary certification programs, we strive to look beyond checklists and develop deeper insights into how institutions support research excellence.

The DORA Declaration reminds us that quality isn’t always visible in numbers. Some of the most meaningful work happens in local languages, interdisciplinary teams, or open-access platforms—areas that have often been overlooked by traditional evaluation systems.

We see DORA not as a challenge to existing standards but as a complementary framework. It encourages us to ask better questions:

• Are researchers encouraged to share their data and collaborate?

• Are institutions recognizing a wide range of research contributions?

• Is teaching and community impact considered alongside publications?

By integrating these dimensions into our auditing practices, we move closer to what true academic quality looks like.

Current Momentum and Global Conversations

This week, renewed discussions have emerged around the implementation of DORA principles. More and more institutions are revising promotion policies, shifting hiring practices, and changing how research is funded. There’s a clear move away from the obsession with rankings and impact factors, and toward a culture that values ethical, rigorous, and socially relevant research.

For PINO Switzerland, this trend is encouraging. It affirms the importance of our work in fostering quality systems that are transparent, fair, and tailored to institutional missions—not just international prestige.

Our Commitment

At PINO Switzerland, we are:

• Encouraging clients to align their research policies with DORA-inspired principles

• Updating our inspection and peer-review tools to assess real academic value

• Supporting institutions in building frameworks that reward originality and integrity

• Recognizing diverse forms of knowledge production, including interdisciplinary and practice-based research

While our certifications are voluntary, the impact of our audits reaches far. We believe that true recognition comes not from conformity, but from commitment to continuous improvement and ethical practice.

Looking Ahead

The DORA Declaration is more than a document—it’s a philosophy. It’s a reminder that excellence is not defined by external labels but by the value a contribution brings to knowledge, society, and future generations.

As this global conversation deepens, PINO Switzerland remains dedicated to being part of the solution. We will continue to support institutions that share our vision of quality grounded in fairness, innovation, and purpose.

#AcademicIntegrity

#ResearchReform

#QualityBeyondMetrics

#DORAPrinciples

#PINOInspection